CMU squashes false tale with story of growing relations
Seed-saving leads to indigenous relationships
WINNIPEG, Man. — Canadian Mennonite University made headlines this fall when it was revealed that workers at the CMU Farm, in collaboration with members of the Métis community, had successfully grown an ancient variety of squash from seeds shared with them by the White Earth Seed Library in Minnesota.
The story that accompanied the “Gete-Okosomin” squash seeds was that they were found in a clay ball at an archaeological excavation near the Wisconsin-Illinois border. It went on to suggest that the dating of the clay ball indicated that the seeds were more than 800 years old.
The story captured the imagination of seed savers and gardeners across the continent. It is a good story, but is it true?
When asked, Kenton Lobe, instructor in international development studies and one of the CMU Farm’s founders, smiles.
“The truth of the story of these squash seeds is still emerging,” he said.
Further digging into the history reveals that they were originally gifted to David Wrone, a University of Wisconsin emeritus historian, by some elder women gardeners from the Miami Nation in Indiana in 1995.
One of these squash had been grown and saved by the Miami people for many generations, perhaps even thousands of years.
In a note to the White Earth Seed Library, Wrone related that he had earlier received squash seeds that had been found deep underground in a Kentucky cave.
They were well preserved and estimated to be several thousand years old. Wrone grew them, but they were “smallish and not as tasty.”
The seeds from the Miami women were shared with Wrone and eventually with White Earth Seed Library.
Over time and through many tellings, these two squash seed stories crossed and turned into one.
The seeds shared with the CMU Farm were, in fact, those grown by the Miami women.
During the last three growing seasons, members of the Metanoia Farmers Worker Cooperative, who work the CMU Farm, collaborated with Caroline Chartrand, who describes herself as “the landless Métis seed saver,” to grow the seeds and maintain the varietal purity.
Their pioneering hand-pollinating method involves community members in planting and caring for the plants and in harvesting the seed to share with others.
Megan Klassen-Wiebe, one of the farmers, presented this methodology at the Indigenous Farming Conference at White Earth Indian Reservation in 2013.
“When we started the CMU Farm, we talked a lot about seeds — the politics of seeds and the role they play in our global agriculture system,” she said. “To have connected with Caroline and be doing seed-saving work is exciting.”
Lobe said that whether or not the original story is true, growing the squash has helped forge relationships between Métis and Mennonites, with Anishinaabe people in Minnesota and, ultimately, with Miami gardeners.
“The truth is, the work of seed- saving has opened up space for indigenous-settler dialogue and has been both hopeful and helpful,” he said, noting that the CMU Farm lies on what in the 1870s was a Métis river lot that is still part of Treaty 1 territory.
Chartrand said seed-saving is important in Métis culture because, in one sense, every time a variety of vegetables goes extinct, part of Métis history is sacrificed.
“I can’t tell you how much I appreciate this partnership I have with Kenton and the farmers at CMU,” she said. “As a re-sult of our work, we have varieties of seeds that were once rare that are now in seed libraries across Canada and the United States.”
The squash seeds will eventually be available for sharing through the fledgling Red River Regional Seed Library at CMU.
Mennonite World Review invites readers’ comments on articles. To promote constructive dialogue, editors select the comments that appear, just as we do with letters to the editor in print. These decisions are final. Writers must sign their first and last names; anonymous comments are not accepted. Comments do not appear until approved and are posted during business hours. Comments may be reproduced in print, and may be edited if selected for print.