Brethren in Christ propose changing MWC’s name

May 16, 2016 by and

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Mennonite World Conference is considering a request to change its name to something more inclusive of its diverse members.

Women of the Brethren in Christ Church of Zimbabwe at the 2003 Mennonite World Conference assembly in Bulawayo, Zimbabwe. — Paul Schrag/MWR

Women of the Brethren in Christ Church of Zimbabwe at the 2003 Mennonite World Conference assembly in Bulawayo, Zimbabwe. — Paul Schrag/MWR

César García, MWC general secretary, said leaders of the Brethren in Christ Church in the U.S., a longtime member of MWC, sent the request to MWC early this year.

“This is not the first time this kind of discussion goes on,” García said. While the idea of changing MWC’s name had been raised in informal conversations, this was the first formal request in recent years.

The BIC letter did not suggest any specific name alternatives, García said.

Alan Robinson, national director for the BIC Church in the U.S., said the conversation began among the BIC leadership council while preparing for the MWC assembly in Harrisburg, Pa., in 2015.

“Some members of the council suggested that . . . it was not easy to communicate to our members of the Brethren in Christ Church why we’re attending Mennonite World Conference,” Robinson said. “We’re asking Breth­ren in Christ people to attend the conference of another church. That’s how it sounds to them.”

Additionally, he said, local news outlets repeatedly referred to the MWC assembly as a gathering of Mennonites.

“I thought to myself, ‘It’s not just Mennonites; there are others who are part of this gathering,’ ” Robinson said. “The term ‘Mennonite’ communicates a denominational identity. So why would we encourage our people to go to the conference meetings of another denomination? For clarity of communication, it was problematic.”

Robinson said BIC members familiar with MWC history would not have had those misunderstandings, but newer members had some confusion.

Possible timeline

At the annual MWC Executive Committee meeting in February, committee members decided to consider the BIC request. García said the MWC Faith and Life Commission now has the task to propose how a possible name change could be done.

The conversation is only in the beginning stages, but the Faith and Life Commission could pre­sent its proposal — and possibly suggestions for new names — at the 2017 Executive Committee meeting.

If approved, the proposal would be voted on at the 2018 meeting of the MWC General Council, which is composed of delegates from each member denomination and meets every three years. García said the General Council was scheduled to meet in April 2018 in Kenya.

But even prior to the BIC request, some name ideas were discussed.

“There have been some informal conversations about changing the name to ‘community’ or ‘communion’ ” García said. “ ‘Anabaptist World Community’ or ‘Anabaptist World Communion’ would be more accurate to what we are. However, there are many reasons why members want to keep the [current] name.”

García said MWC wanted to move forward with discussing the request.

“It pushed Mennonite World Conference to think about our identity,” he said.

History: The Brethren in Christ Church began in the 1770s in Pennsylvania with roots in the Anabaptist, Pietist and Wesleyan/holiness traditions. César García, Mennonite World Conference general secretary, said the denomination has historically been a strong supporter and involved member of MWC. It also participates in Mennonite Central Committee.

The BIC Church has been prominent in MWC in recent years, especially through its large presence in Zimbabwe. The 45,000-member BIC Church in Zimbabwe hosted the 2003 MWC assembly. BIC Bishop Danisa Ndlovu of Zimbabwe was president of MWC from 2009 to 2015.

Comments Policy

Mennonite World Review invites readers’ comments on articles. To promote constructive dialogue, editors select the comments that appear, just as we do with letters to the editor in print. These decisions are final. Writers must sign their first and last names; anonymous comments are not accepted. Comments do not appear until approved and are posted during business hours. Comments may be reproduced in print, and may be edited if selected for print.

  • Conrad Ermle

    Brethren in Christ are a different denomination. No wonder their people wonder why they are going to another denomination’s world conference. The name Mennonite should be retained. – Conrad Ermle.

    • Billy Bass

      I agree! One possible solution that could be a little more inclusive could be to name it something like “Anabaptist-Mennonite Associated World Conference”. All in all, if denominations don’t matter as much, then there shouldn’t be discussion of changing the name at all!
      – Billy S-K Bass

    • R. Aubrey Hawton

      But MWC is not just made up of Mennonite churches. As the article states, the BIC have been longtime MWC and MCC members. So, can you explain why the name “Mennonite” should be retained, Conrad?

  • Conrad Martin

    How ironic that the “Brethren” In Christ want a more inclusive name.

    • R. Aubrey Hawton

      This year, the Canadian BIC will be debating/discussing a name change.

  • Steven Stubble

    In the universal church of our Lord, names like Lutheran, Mennonite and Anabaptist are based on human tradition and are utterly meaningless; they should have been jettisoned long ago. The ethnic designation of some church as “Mennonite” is nothing more than an additional hurdle to jump over, and gets in the way of people understanding what it means to be a Christian. Did Luther die for our sins? Were we baptized in the name of Menno? At best, it’s a quaint relic of our ancestral past, or a quick-reference denominational label. At worst, it continues to confuse and mislead people into thinking that “Mennonite” EQUALS “Christian”; indeed it deceives Mennonites into believing this damning lie about themselves!

  • Dennis R. Kuhns

    How about Anabaptist World Conference, AWC?

  • Amos Muhagachi

    I agree and support those who want to see the MWC name to be changed because not all Anabaptist are Mennonite but Mennonite are part of Anabaptist I could propose new name to be Anabaptist World Communion of faith, thank you Bishop Amos Muhagachi from Tanzania Mennonite Church.

About Me